HUDC Flats in Singapore: The "OG" Public Housing For Our Sandwich Class

Braddell-View-Ang-Mo-Kio-Bishan-Thomson-Singapore HUDC

Before the executive condominium (EC) came about in 1999, aspiring ‘sandwich class’ Singaporeans who wanted something between an HDB flat and a private condo had the Housing and Urban Development Company, or HUDC flat.

Though HUDC was discontinued in 1987, it’s still one of the most popular HDB property types in Singapore. And today, we’re going to tell you why.

 

What are HUDC flats

As mentioned above, HUDC flats were the predecessors of ECs. 

They were introduced by the government to cater to middle-income Singaporeans who could afford more than an HDB flat, but still consider private homes a bridge too far.

HUDCs were developed between 1975 and 1987 in four phases; phase one and two were developed by HUDC Private Limited, and phase three and four by HDB. In total, 7,731 units were built across 18 HUDC estates over the span of 12 years. 

Back then, HUDC flats were popular as private homes and housing types were quite limited. However, due to dwindling demand as well as more available housing options in the market, the HUDC scheme eventually ended in 1987.

In terms of characteristics, HUDCs were typically larger, better built and also had better amenities compared to regular HDB flats, such as covered carparks and sheltered grounds. The largest HUDC flat was 1,700 sq ft, which is amongst the biggest HDB flats ever constructed.

In 1995, the government introduced plans to allow HUDC to be privatised with at least 75% approval votes from the owners; the first HUDC to be privatised was Amberville in Katong.

Since then, all HUDC flats have been privatised, with the last being Brandell View in 2017. As such, when talking about HUDC in today’s context, we’re actually referring to ex-HUDC flats. 

 

What makes HUDC flats popular

There are three main reasons why HUDC flats are popular:

1. They are well-built, spacious and located in good locales

As mentioned, HUDC flats were originally catered for buyers who want to own private properties, but couldn’t quite afford to buy a private condo. 

Though the scheme required buyers to pay a premium, HUDC flats boast spacious interiors, ranging between 139 and 158 sq m. This is ideal for those who want a privatised home with spacious interiors.

Another selling point of HUDC flats is that they are located in prime locations with good amenities such Marine Parade, Bishan, Toa Payoh and Novena. This is a stark contrast to ECs — which are usually located in outskirt areas such as Sembawang and Sengkang and are slightly further away from amenities such as MRT stations, schools and malls.

Apart from space and location, HUDC flats are also better-built compared to their HDB counterparts. 

Over the course of its 12 years in production, there have been very few complaints about its quality. This is very much unlike another HDB flat type, the Design, Build, and Sell Scheme (DBSS) flat, which was known for problems such as poor workmanship, designs and defects.

2. They aren’t bound by HDB’s rules

Since all HUDC flats are now privatised, you can buy a resale HUDC flat without worrying about HDB rules.

For example, there’s no 5-year Minimum Occupancy Period (MOP) restriction, which means you can rent it out immediately after buying it and start collecting rental income. 

You can also sell it immediately, but bear in mind that you’re subjected to Seller’s Stamp Duty (SSD) if you sell it within the first three years. 

3. Potential for en bloc

Perhaps one of the well-known facts of HUDC flats is that they have a high potential for en bloc. The first HUDC flat to undergo an en bloc sale was Amberville, which was sold for $183 million in 2006

Since then, several eye-catching en bloc sales have followed over the years. Most notably, Farrer Court was sold for a whopping $1.3 billion in 2007 — which is the priciest en bloc deal to date. 

Of the 18 HUDC estates that were built, all but five have undergone en bloc sales:

Amberville

Marine Parade

168

Sold for $168 million 

2006

Waterfront View

Bedok

583

Sold for $385 million

2006

Minton Rise

Hougang

342

Sold for $209 million 

2007

Gilman Heights

Bukit Merah

607

Sold for $548 million

2007

Farrer Court

Bukit Timah

618

Sold for $1.3 billion

2007

Shunfu Ville

Bishan

358

Sold for $638 million

2006

Raintree Gardens

Toa Payoh

175

Sold for $334.2 million

2016

Rio Casa

Hougang

286

Sold for $575 million

2017

Florence Regency

Hougang

336

Sold for $329 million

2017

Serangoon Ville

Serangoon

244

Sold for $499 million

2017

Tampines Court

Tampines

560

Sold for $970 million

2017

Eunosville

Geylang

330

Sold for $765 million

2017

Chancery Court

Novena

136

Sold for $401.78 million

2018

-

Braddell View

Toa Payoh

48

Unsold

-

-

Ivory Heights

Jurong

654

Unsold

-

-

Laguna Park

Marine Parade

516

Unsold

-

-

Lakeview Estate

Bishan

240

Unsold

-

-

Pine Grove

Clementi/ Bukit Timah

660

Unsold

-

-

 

But there are actually more than 18 HUDC flats in Singapore

Officially, there are 18 HUDC flats. However, there's actually three more. These were initially built as affordable condo homes for government officials working for the Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) and Ministry of Finance (MOF), before they were available for the public.

So far, only Normanton Park has undergone a collective sale (in 2017 for $830.1 million by Kingsfold Hurray Development), while the remaining two remain unsold:

Neptune Court
Marine Parade
752
Unsold
Lagoon View
Marine Parade
480
Unsold 
-
Normanton Park
Queenstown
488
Sold for $830.1 million
2017
One Normanton Park

 

Are HUDC flats good investments?

Though HUDC flats have a good en bloc track record, that doesn’t mean it’s guaranteed.

In fact, the remaining HUDC flats have attempted to go for en-bloc several times over the years, without success. 

Brandell View, which is the largest private residential property in Singapore, was in the market twice in the space of three months, but failed to receive the $2.08 billion asking price.

Meanwhile, Ivory Heights was unable to secure the necessary 80% approval rate, while Pine Grove’s $1.8 billion tender received no bids. 

Before buying an HUDC flat, also consider the remaining lease. Remember, the remaining HUDC flats were built between the 70s and 90s; which means some have less than 60 years lease left. Banks will also restrict the financing of the home for properties with shorter leases. 

That being said, HUDC flats have their benefits. 

As explained above, they are comparatively larger than most HDB and private properties, and are also privatised properties in good locations. These are valid aspects to consider, especially since the work-from-home trend during the COVID-19 pandemic has seen demand for bigger homes has gone up as more are opting for bigger homes, whether they want to cater a dedicated workspace or small office at home, or need more privacy.  

Bearing the above in mind, good luck in finding your new home!

 

Looking for HUDC flats for sale?

Find remaining HUDC flats for sale below:

 

For more property news, resources and useful content like this article, check out PropertyGuru’s guides section

Are you looking to buy a new home? Head to PropertyGuru to browse the top properties for sale in Singapore.  

Already found a new home? Let PropertyGuru Finance's home finance advisors help you with financing it.

Read Next